水草情迷

水草tank可以用隔屎板ma?
會唔會傷根???

絕對唔係一個好既做法。 底濾主要係用砂養菌， 定期又要清理， 同養草底砂/泥既要求完全唔同。 加上肥又會走入水， 又唔落得根肥， 又會帶大量氧影響根部吸收等等原因。

_________________
Bye Bye Mash BB! 你要保重， 你永遠係我既乖BB。

thx~Macbrush ~u always can ans my question~

我的24"x8"x9" 用緊! 因知道對co2流失有影响, 但又真覺得好似幾好,所以都keep 着每天6-8小時開泵!
用底濾原因如下.
1/ 因為已經買了才知道会令co2流失.
2/ 用了真係水助Ｄ水快d清, 微塵給泥底隔了, 浸得块.
3/ 爬文得知, 增加泥層水流,有助泥層健康. (泥底暖管同樣道理), 但沒有斫究過優/缺點對草/蝦缸,哪樣佔多!
4/ 我的缸只有eden501, 水流不是很強. 用co2後會有一片油脂在水面積聚, 不知為何,只要(在停co2後)用氣泵用底濾, 油脂自然清除.
5/ 總覺得水流太慢,開了氣泵好像多点生氣.

My 2 cents..
Thx!

可以話係負面多過正面，一係好似我咁，另外一個濾桶做底濾，出入水口都係底，加多支暖管利用溫差做對流。

根就唔會點傷，不過d根就可能會'乸'住d底喉或底板，而唔用既主要原因係唔想爆發藻類。

封了出氣口
可加多一個小桶

5明AR....CHING

I also heard that many people say it's no good to use 隔屎板. I've used it for 3 yrs and here are some comments:

1/ co2流失
- CO2 only open with light that 8 hr only/ day, you can switch on the 隔屎板pump out of these hours
- Open CO2 larger can compensate the loss as CO2, my CO2 tester always show it's enough

2/ 用了真係水助Ｄ水快d清, 微塵給泥底隔了, 浸得块.
Yes, I use DIY 隔屎板 + 1500L/hr pump, very fast for cleaning, strong water current also hope cleaning the plant surface

3/ 爬文得知, 增加泥層水流,有助泥層健康. (泥底暖管同樣道理)
Yes, use the soil for growing bacteria

4/ 我的缸只有eden501, 水流不是很強. 用co2後會有一片油脂在水面積聚, 不知為何,只要(在停co2後)用氣泵用底濾, 油脂自然清除

5/ 總覺得水流太慢,開了氣泵好像多点生氣.
I open 氣泵 at mid-night

總覺得水流太慢,開了氣泵好像多點生氣

生氣係來自缸內的植物，唔係靠個氣泵

一般氣動隔屎板都連有一條硬管，硬管頂有個窿比你放氣石入去打氣,如果你唔想再用，又暫時唔想翻缸取出隔屎板，咁你可以拆走呢條管(一般都係可裝可拆的，動作當然要小心)，D水草砂/泥自然會填返個接駁口，剩抵塊隔屎板喺底無大問題，遲d翻缸再算。

如嫌水流、水循環真的太細太少，細缸都可加多一個小濾桶既，如Eden501/511。

_________________
與你的朋友分享水族樂趣

仲有玩草用隔屎板係廿年前ｄ人先會咁做

_________________
與你的朋友分享水族樂趣

"仲有玩草用隔屎板係廿年前ｄ人先會咁做" .......ha ?

Sorry, some fish friends including me are still using 隔屎板 in our aquarium tanks now .

I think it's very difficult to jump to the conclusion that the design of 隔屎板 is good or not as it's depending the setting of your aqua tank .

May be...I'm too "law"... haha...

However, I truly believe gravel filter has many more cons than pros for planted tank, if there is any pro at all. Besides, to keep a truly effective gravel filter, regular cleaning is required, I don't know how this could be done in a planted tank. IMHO, doable isn't equal to suitable, there are plants can survive on just about anything that's wet.

Just my 2 cents.

_________________
Bye Bye Mash BB! 你要保重， 你永遠係我既乖BB。